American Idol: Old Or New?

So many people have been complaining about missing Paula and Simon..So I asked on facebook, "Do you like the Old American Idol or the New One? There were mixed responses and some decided they would rather watch a Tortoise Race, but some loved it!  Here are some responses:1.Shalli So'Excited Shello- the old onee....simon was the bestt!!

2. Ashley Saucier Gibson -I like the old one. I think it is better for someone, Simon, to tell you straight up than someone give you false hope and lie to you

3. Laci Saunders- New one for sure!!! 100 percent better! They don't put anyone down on the new show

4. Jeremy Faul- J lo n tyler

5. Brad Vincent-  Simon was the man, but JLo is sooo Hot, and Steven just cracks me up

What did everybody else say? Are you part of the cool club, just kidding